More Places I Hang Out

Quid Pro Quills - A Group of 6 Writers... Writing!
Twin Willows Farm - My Farm and Fiber Arts Webpage
Great Lakes ACFW Chapter - My Local Chapter of the American Christian Fiction Writers

Subscribe Via E-Mail

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Powered by Blogger.


Copyright by Pegg Thomas 2009-2015


free counter
Sep 2, 2012
Winterdance: The Fine Madness of Running the IditarodWinterdance: The Fine Madness of Running the Iditarod by Gary Paulsen

My rating: 2 of 5 stars

Dog sledding, and particularly the Iditarod, have interested me for years.  I find the whole idea of moving across vast areas of frozen nature behind the bushy tails of sled dogs fascinating.  This book proves that out.  I'd still like to try it some day!

Parts of this book had me laughing out loud.  If you appreciate dogs in any capacity, you'll enjoy that aspect of "Winterdance."  Gary Paulsen does a great job of showing us what it really means to work and live with the dogs.  He gives us a wonderful view of their personalities.  He also brings the Alaskan wilderness to life in a personal way.

I didn't like the ending.  The whole story is one man's experiences - which by nature are going to be self-centered - but the ending was a total wallow in self absorption.  He didn't end with the Iditarod, or the dogs, or the thrill of accomplishment.  He ended with his failing health and it adding absolutely nothing to the story. 

There is a lot of foul language throughout the book.  I'm sure it's all authentic, it's how the mushers talk, etc.  But it wasn't necessary to get the feel and flavor of the Iditarod and it makes the book completely unsuitable for younger readers.

I'd like to give this one 2 1/2 stars, because I can recommend it to some people, but not others.


Melissa said...

Good post. It's always nice to see a fair and honest review. I despise fluffy 5-stars that aren't earned.

PS - Thanks for your faithful support of GPM. Hang in there. It's going to get nudged and or merged a couple of times in the next few weeks, but I'm trying not to totally preempt anymore. ;)

by Pegg Thomas said...

No fluffy 5 stars here. If I give a book 5 stars, it has to completely knock my socks off.

I love Grammar Police Monday! And recommend that others check it out. I didn't comment last week because... well... I didn't like that cover at all. Was following the old-old advice of, "if you can't say something nice..."

Melissa said...

I've read the ARC. Believe it or not, the writing is pretty good. ;)